🔗 Share this article

Transgender documentarian Sam Feder's newest documentary "Heightened Scrutiny" offers a compelling dual perspective – simultaneously an emotional portrait of a prominent trans advocate and a pointed analysis of journalistic reporting surrounding transgender issues.

Judicial Battle at the Highest Court

This feature documents ACLU attorney Chase Strangio as he gears up for court proceedings in the landmark Supreme Court case the Skirmetti case. This legal battle took place in December 2024, with the judiciary ultimately ruling in favor of the state's case, effectively permitting limitations on medical transition for trans minors to remain in effect across numerous US territories.

We made Heightened Scrutiny in merely 16 months, shared Feder during an interview. Meanwhile, my previous film Disclosure took me five years, so this was quite rushed. Our intention was to generate dialogue so people would learn more about the case.

Personal Narrative Amid Political Struggle

Although Feder provides a extensive examination of how prominent publications have promoted transphobic narratives, the film's primary accomplishment may be its compelling depiction of Strangio. Usually a reserved attorney in media appearances, Strangio displays his vulnerability throughout the film.

This represented a substantial challenge, to reveal aspects of my life to a documentary crew that I had worked hard to keep personal, explained Strangio. Feder said he wanted future generations to know that we struggled, to see what was done in support of these fights for our material survival.

Varied Voices in the Struggle

To enhance Strangio's narrative, Feder includes multiple transgender voices, such as prominent leaders from journalism and the arts. The documentary also includes viewpoints from non-trans supporters who examine how respected media outlets have added to damaging portrayals of transgender people.

The viewpoint of trans youth key to the legal case is represented through a impressive young activist named Mila. Viewers observe her fighting for her community at a educational meeting, with subsequent footage showing her protesting for trans rights outside the highest court.

Intimate Scenes Beyond the Legal Battle

The documentary also features touching moments where Feder steps outside the never-ending legal struggle, such as footage of Strangio traveling in Italy and getting a tattoo featuring lines from activist Pauli Murray's poem "Prediction."

This body art moment is one of my preferred parts in the movie, explained Strangio. Getting inked is nearly like a meditative experience for me, to be completely aware in my body and to consider it as a vehicle for things that are meaningful to me.

Body Autonomy and Portrayal

The filmmaker's dedication to lovingly documenting Strangio getting to his tattoo collection highlights that this documentary is fundamentally about trans bodies – not just those of youth who experience prohibition of their ability to live genuinely in their own bodies, but also the bodies of the numerous participants who are featured in the documentary.

I make films with a meaning, and part of that is selecting people who are outstanding and concise enough to carry the camera, shared Feder. When people ask me what they should wear for an interview, my reply is whatever makes you feel hot. This is important to me – as transgender individuals, we struggle so much with our self-perception.

Impact and Optimism

One aspect that makes Feder's films shine is his evident skill for making his transgender interviewees feel at ease, seen and valued. This approach fosters authentic chemistry between Feder and Strangio, helping the director to realize his objective of showing Strangio as a multifaceted individual and leaving a testament for future generations of how resiliently he and others have fought for transgender liberties.

I don't want people to find themselves in a situation of perpetual hopelessness because of what the law is not giving us, explained Strangio. I aim to be in a practice of using the law to lessen harm, but not to transform it into some sort of pathway for our liberatory possibilities. The government is not going to be the reflection through which we view ourselves. Our community are that reflection, and it's extremely vital that we keep having that conversation in addition to dialogues about resisting these policies and procedures.

This important documentary is currently accessible for streaming during Trans Visibility Week and will receive a broader release at a subsequent date.